How I Packed for NYC in Winter (As a West Coast Girl)

I just got back from a trip to New York City, and as a California native, I definitely wasn’t prepared for January on the East Coast. With NYC at its coldest, my outfit planning required a bit of extra prep to ensure I didn’t spend the whole trip miserably cold.

How to Choose: Wool Coat vs. Puffer

One of the things I had a hard time deciding on while packing was whether to bring a wool coat or a puffer jacket. I ultimately ended up bringing both, and I’m glad I did! The temperature varied enough for them to both be useful.

When deciding which to reach for, I realized it really comes down to whether the temperature is above or below freezing, and if it is wet or dry.

Above freezing (35°–50°): Wool wins.

New York was made for a long wool coat. I loved it on dry days when the temperature stayed just above freezing. It’s breathable, polished, and perfect for walking in and out of warm shops. On colder or windier days, I relied on cashmere gloves and earmuffs to help make up for the lack of insulation.

Below freezing (32° and under): Puffer, no question.

Once the temperature dropped or the wind picked up, the puffer was my go-to. The way wind cuts through the city can make a cold day feel extra cold, and a puffer just does a better job at keeping the warmth in. The only downside is the subway heat, so I kept whatever I wore underneath light and simple.

Wool Coats

Try to look for a wool coat that’s 100% wool, or as close to it as possible. Pure wool keeps you warm without that plastic, sweaty feeling you get from synthetics, and it has a heavier, more luxurious drape that gets better with age.

I already had a simple wool coat from Aritzia that I bought a few years ago, but these are the styles I’d upgrade to next.

Puffer Jackets

I picked up the Aritzia Super Puff last minute, the day before I left. I wasn’t sure I’d actually need a heavy puffer, but looking back, I’m so glad I did.

It’s known for its 700+ fill power goose down, so it’s very warm without feeling heavy. It also comes in a ton of colors and a few different lengths, which makes it easy to find one that suits your style.

Base Layers

From my research, the two best options for base layers are Uniqlo’s Ultra Heattech thermals or merino wool thermals. Merino is the superior material because it is a natural fiber, breathable, and doesn’t trap sweat or hold onto odor the way synthetic fabrics can. I tried to order merino thermals for this trip, but they didn’t arrive in time, so I went with Uniqlo instead.

And honestly? I was pleasantly surprised. The Heattech layers kept me warm without feeling bulky, and I never once felt cold in my arms or legs. One day I wore them as leggings, and another day under my jeans. If you’re looking for a reliable, affordable base layer, Uniqlo is a solid option, but I’ll probably upgrade to merino layers eventually.

Warm Accessories

If you want to stay warm in the cold, you’ve got to protect the parts of your body that lose heat the fastest — your head, ears, and hands. That’s why scarves, earmuffs, and cashmere gloves were the real MVPs for me.

A scarf keeps wind from sneaking in at your neck, earmuffs keep your ears from freezing, and cashmere gloves keep your hands warm without making them sweaty. These are the small pieces that make the biggest difference when you’re outside all day.

Waterproof Shoes/Boots

In NYC winter, waterproof shoes are basically non-negotiable. Between slush, puddles, and surprise rain, you want something that can handle it all.

I wore my Sorel Chelsea boots, and they were the perfect mix of practical and cute. They kept my feet dry, had good traction, and didn’t feel bulky.

The combo of all these things kept me cozy and warm during my January NYC trip! If you’re planning a winter trip to NYC, keep it simple, pack smart, and prioritize the items that make you feel warm and put together.